[It takes him a moment to realize how she might have interpreted his hestiancy and expression, and his cheeks flush as he shakes his head a bit too vigorously. He didn't want her to think he was reluctant to win her things! Far from that, honestly-- it was the toy he wasn't crazy about, not the idea of getting it for her.]

N-No, if you like it, I can get it for you! I'm more than happy to win you anything you want!

[And it's said with such earnestness that it's clear he wasn't just saying this to make her feel better. Sure, it wasn't obligatory for him to do it just because they were dating, but he wanted to do this for her, regardless. Her happiness was his happiness, after all, and it was times like these he could show off his skills a little and impress her a little in the process.

His eyes travel back over to the plush, however, a crease settling in his brow.]

But... don't you think it looks a bit familiar...?